Peter Ulintz Peter Ulintz
Technical Director

Solutions for Galling

October 31, 2022


During my die design and die maintenance seminars, I often take informal surveys by asking attendees, “What are the top five or six die-related problems in your press shop?” 

The 10 most-common responses:

  • Misfeeds (usually the number-one response)
  • Slug pulling (a close second)
  • Strip not feeding straight (aligned) through the die
  • Galling
  • Wrinkles and/or splits
  • Dimensional variation
  • Tool-steel chipping/wear
  • Tool breakage 
  • Scrap and slivers in the die
  • Sensors shutting the press (nuisance faults).

In a series of my prior columns, Improving Progressive Die Performance (MetalForming magazine October through December 2021), I addressed several of these problems. 

The most-common problem occurring during coil change: coil-stock misfeed. Improper positioning of the leading end of the coil strip can be responsible for more die damage during the first 10 strokes of the press than the next 10,000 strokes.

Another problem, slug pulling, results from a vacuum created when the perforating punch withdraws from a hole. This usually occurs after increasing punch-to-die cutting clearances to improve hole edge conditions, or to reduce stripping forces or cutting pressures. Sometimes, die components are replaced and a die-maintenance person may increase the cutting clearance slightly to help increase tool life. As a result, a slug previously retained adequately with die clearances of 5 to 8 percent per side now may pull out of the die matrix after the clearances are increased to 10 percent per side or greater.

Sometimes, galling can be self-inflicted when die engineers inadvertently overlook a fundamental principle in deep drawing: In-plane compression of the sheet metal causes an increase in sheet thickness.

Four Rules for Galling Reduction

1. Ensure that corner draw-forming sections have proper punch-to-die clearance for the magnitude of material thickening occurring in that portion of the die.

The arrival of CNC machining and 3D modeling has reduced the amount of time required to design, machine and assemble die components. One technique having sped up this process: the ability to cut clearance into the punch or die cavity by offsetting the cutter path by maximum material thickness. This works well until encountering a deep-drawn formed corner.

The corners in any box or irregularly shaped geometry will form in the same manner as with cylindrical cup drawing. The corners feature compressive stress on the metal moving toward the die entry and tensile stress on the metal drawn over the die radius. As a result, thickness changes that initially occurred in the flange move into the vertical wall. Consequently, the corner of the panel lacks maximum material-thickness clearance.

To reduce the likelihood of galling in draw corners, additional punch-to-die clearance must be machined in the vertical wall. To keep sheet metal flowing freely into the corner wall, the draw pad also needs additional clearance around the corners so that the thicker flange does not “pinch” the material and restrict flow. This generally requires the use of analytical tools such as metal forming simulations to achieve cost-effective results. The additional corner clearance reduces galling tendency far better—and at lower cost—than adding a surface coating. If tight corner clearance is the root cause, adding a surface treatment literally coats the problem —an expensive solution.

2. Polish all die sections for corner draws as if prepping for a surface-coating application.

Surface coatings—very expensive to apply—result in close attention paid to the heat treatment process and the quality of die polishing. Oftentimes, this level of attention greatly exceeds that given to die sections not considered for surface coating. Thus, performance improvements sometimes attributed to surface coatings may instead result from a high-quality surface-preparation process. To determine this, verify that the die component has been machined with the proper amount of clearance to accommodate thickening, and polish to a level acceptable for coating application. Next, install the die sections in the die without coating them and then document the results.

3. Address adhesive-wear problems directly.

If galling persists, increase the wear resistance of the die component and reduce the contact friction between the tooling and the workpiece. This requires proper tool-steel selection and heat treatment to ensure surface hardness that resists abrasive wear. Proper lubrication selection and application reduces contact friction.

4. Address lubrication only after complying with rules 1 through 3. 

Usually, lubrication represents the first countermeasure attempted—a quick, low-cost solution—when galling persists. However, if not the root cause, lubrication proves a short-lived solution. As changes in material thickness, friction conditions, process temperature and adhesive-wear conditions vary over time, so will the effectiveness of the lubricant. The typical countermeasure: Change the lubricant concentration or change out for something “better.” Oftentimes, the problem area ends up flooded with a constant flow of lubricant, creating a housekeeping issue and increased operational costs.

Using the proper lubricant and controlling its application (volume and location) prove crucial to a successful stamping operation. However, this approach is most effective when not used to offset die-related problems.

Follow these four rules before pursuing surface treatments. Otherwise, the expensive coating may do nothing more than cover up an underlying—and perhaps less-expensive—die problem. MF

Next month: Addressing tool steel chipping and wear.

Industry-Related Terms: Abrasive, CNC, Corner, Die, Draw, Drawing, Edge, Flange, Form, Forming, Polishing, Scrap, Slug, Stripping, Surface, Thickness
View Glossary of Metalforming Terms

Technologies: Tooling

Comments

Must be logged in to post a comment.
There are no comments posted.

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Start receiving newsletters.